Selasa, 08 Juli 2014

High Court challenge: Government admits holding asylum seekers

Tags

By political correspondent Emma Griffiths

Related Story: High Court case may shed light on Tamils' fate

Related Story: High Court to consider legality of asylum seeker transfer

Government lawyers have told a High Court hearing 72 hours' notice will be given before 153 asylum seekers being held on a Customs ship are handed back to Sri Lankan authorities.

Lawyers acting for about one third of the asylum seekers, whose whereabouts the Government refuses to disclose, are seeking to challenge the legality of the Commonwealth's actions.

Today's hearing in Melbourne was given the first official confirmation that the asylum seekers - including children as young as 2 - have been intercepted and are being held on a Customs vessel.

Twenty-one of the asylum seekers are minors, aged between 2 and 16 years of age. The majority of the group as a whole are males.

Ron Merkel QC, who is acting for the asylum seekers, told the court the boat was intercepted in Australian waters and that there was evidence it was in "trouble" at the time.

However Solicitor-General Justin Gleeson said the boat was found in Australia's contiguous zone - not the migration zone - and argued that the passengers had no right to claim asylum in Australia.

"People who reach the contiguous zone have no rights under the act," he told the court.

Mr Gleeson said the 72 hours' notice would be given to the asylum seekers' lawyers if a decision was made to hand them over.

He said the commitment to provide notice was "given without any admissions on any matter of fact or law".

Mr Merkel said the issue was not whether the government had power to take the 153 people on board an Australian vessel, but whether they could be forcibly returned to Sri Lanka.

The court has yet to decide if the lawyers have a case to be heard, but if the application is accepted it could prevent the asylum seekers being handed over to Sri Lankan authorities.

However Sri Lanka's high commissioner to Australia, Admiral Thisara Samarasinghe, says his country has no plans to accept the group, who are believed to have set sail from a port in India.

"I can categorically deny and reject any plans of Sri Lanka to take over the suspected, speculated, presumed asylum seekers coming from India," he told ABC News 24.

The hearing has now been adjourned until Friday morning, when the Government's lawyers are expected to provide documents including details of the asylum seekers' names.

The case is expected to be back before the High Court within 21 days for a directions hearing, which will decide if the case should proceed to a hearing before the full bench.

Justice Crennan has given lawyers of the asylum seekers seven days to file a statement of claim, after which the Government has seven days to respond.

While the court proceedings continue, it is not known what will happen to the asylum seekers on board the boat.

Mr Merkel has asked the Government's lawyers to give him notice if the asylum seekers will be transferred to Manus Island or Nauru.

Government says processing can include on-water teleconferencing

In Canberra, the Government has confirmed that teleconferencing of asylum seekers at sea "may" be used in what it is calling the "enhanced screening" of asylum claims.

There have been reports that Australian authorities have conducted basic interviews with the asylum seekers via video link - a method that has been criticised by refugee advocates.

Forty-one asylum seekers were transferred to the Sri Lankan navy earlier this week, after being assessed at sea through the "enhanced screening" process.

Government leader in the Senate Eric Abetz told Senate question time that "clearly enhanced processing may well include teleconferencing".

Assistant Immigration Minister Michaelia Cash defended the Government's approach.

"In relation to the enhanced screening process, I advise the Senate that the processes that we have followed in relation to enhanced screening is the same process that was practised by the previous government," she said.

High Court challenge: Government admits holding asylum seekers, pledges 72 hours' notice on any deportation - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)


EmoticonEmoticon